Football Cookie Cake • Recipe for Perfection (2024)

This football cookie cake post has been sponsored by M&M’s and Snickers. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Made with chocolate chocolate chip cookie dough, vanilla frosting, and M&M’s, this fun football cookie cake is very easy to make and perfect for parties.

Football Cookie Cake & More Football Party Ideas

I grew up in a football family.

On Thanksgiving, there was an inevitable football game in the grassy area below my paternal grandfather’s second story condo. Dad, cousins, and uncles gleefully ran around, knocking the fallen leaves into the air.

One of my fondest memories is when my dad, stepmom, and I went to a real, live football game held far away from home in a huge stadium. Our seats just happened to be smack in the middle of the home team’s supporters—our sworn enemies—and they gave us very odd looks every time we cheered at the “wrong” moment.

I got a personal pizza from the concession stand and was as happy as a kid could be.

Somehow, food and football have always gone together. For that reason, I find it natural to associate the big game with intriguing platters and bowls of tasty goodies.

When it comes time to shop for the biggest event in football, I find it convenient to make a Target run. You can pick up everything you need for game day from food, to candy, to party goods. You can save big on your game day goodies with two unique Cartwheel offers:

• Mars & Wrigley Game Day offer, valid 1/1/2017 – 1/14/2017
• Big Game Goodies offer, valid 1/15/2017 – 2/5/2017

I’m even going to dress up my football cookie cake with some M&M’s Peanut candies for a colorful touch.

Plus, I’ll show you a fun party game you can play with the Snickers NFL Minis you can also find at Target.

There’s no better way to celebrate football season than this!

You can also pack up your goodies to go. Use plastic wrap and a little ribbon to make individual treat bags for tailgating.

Since the candies are so colorful and pretty all on their own, I like to use clear glass serving bowls. I also repurpose small shot glasses so that guests can take individual servings of M&M’s Peanut candies.

To play the party game I mentioned, you’ll need 4 crayons and 1 Snickers NFL Mini “football” for each person.

Align the crayons to form a football goal shape with the Snickers NFL Mini in the middle of the goal post.

The challenge is to move only twocrayons in a way that re-creates the entire football goal in the same shape, but with the Snickers NFL Mini sittingoutsideof the goal posts. (You can’t move the Snickers NFL Mini.) Can you do it?

Tips for Making a Football Cookie Cake

• Line your baking sheet with parchment paper for easy release and cleanup.
• Chocolate chocolate chip cookie dough looks most like a football (because it’s brown, of course), but don’t let that stop you from choosing another flavor you like better.
• If you have time, you can easily make your own frosting by beating 1/4 cup room temperature unsalted butter with 2 cups powdered sugar (added a little at a time to the butter, then beating before added more). Add 1/2 teaspoon of vanilla extract and a pinch of salt for flavor.
• Choose your M&M’s Peanut candy decorations according to your team colors.

Find all the best football party supplies, like M&M’s Peanut and SNICKERS NFL Minis, at Target!

Use these Cartwheel offers to save:

• Mars & Wrigley Game Day offer, valid 1/1/2017 – 1/14/2017
• Big Game Goodies offer, valid 1/15/2017 – 2/5/2017